Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Twins: Aggressive or....Status Quo?

The Twins entered the 2013-2014 offseason with a ton of questions and not many answers. The team was decimated by the 3 year run of Bill Smith, who isn't fit to run a Lemonade Stand.

Terry Ryan had taken back control of the team prior to the 2013 season and needed the season to assess the state of the franchise. He didn't make a lot of moves but spent the season evaluating talent or lack thereof.

His first move this offseason was to resign Ron Gardenhire and the coaching staff, which should be commended. Gardenhire has not been given the tools to be successful since 2010.

As the Winter Meetings approached, Ryan signed Ricky Nolasco away fron the Dodgers for 4 years/$49 million and Phil Hughes from the Bronx Bummers for 3 years/$24 million. Truly a great start for a team never very active in free agency, filling their greatest needs.

Terry Ryan promised he was not done and publicly stated he would be very aggressive at the Winter Meetings.

The Winter Meetings came and then they went, without a single transaction.

In the week since Terry Ryan signed Jason Kubel, who was in decline when he left the Twins a couple years ago, to a minor league contract. He has always been a below average defensive player and was never able to hit effectively at Target Field. Then, while playing for Arizona and Cleveland, he put up offensive numbers a career minor leaguer would be ashamed of, while he made $8 million.

Prior to that he did resign Mike Pelfrey, who was a starting picher for the Twins last year, to a 2 year/$12 million contract. This was not a bad move, as Pelfrey will be in his 2nd year removed from Tommy John Surgery, which is typically when pitchers return to form. In addition, it is a low risk move both in terms of dollars and years. If it turned out to be a bad fit , it would not be hard to move the contract.

The problem is, Ryan has not pulled the trigger on any other deals after promising to be aggressive. In fact, the Twins, other than being mentioned in the Brandon Arroyo conversation prior to the Pelfrey signing, have not even been mentioned as suitors in any significant player conversations.

The Twins NEED a power bat, a solid 3B (Plouffe is not the answer), SS, an offensive OF (we have enough 4th & 5th OF candidates), and a catcher. Not to mention other areas could always be upgraded.

Stephen Drew would be a good fit at SS and could probably be had for 4-5 years/$50-75 million. A lot of money but he would be a long term answer, not a project. Miguel Sano figures to be 3B in 2015 maybe late 2014 so all we need is a stop gap. Michael Young, formerly of Texas Rangers fame, would be a solid short term answer as well as future backup/DH. He would also fill the need for power. OF & Catcher could be filled through trade, however there has been zero trade talk involving Twins. Although Byron Buxton does figure to be the starting CF around the same time as Sano at 3B and Josmil Pinto has the potential to be a great catcher if he can improve his calling of a game & defensive ability behind the plate

Bottom line is Terry Ryan has his work cut out and has set the bar high with his early offseason rhetoric. Ron Gardenhire and Twins fans deserve a competitive roster.

The only players that should be off limits, I might miss one or two, are: Miguel Sano, Byron Buxton, Eddie Rosario, Kohl Stewart, and Max Kepler.

Guys that should be on the block: Trevor Plouffe, Ryan Doumit, Josh Willlingham, Aaron Hicks, Chris Parmalee, Alex Wimmers, Vance Worley, Scott Diamond, Sam Deduno, Brian Duensing and many others.

We built you Target Field, time to say thank you and at least try to be competitive. Two new players is too small of a bone, we deserve the whole steak. 1991......22 years....and counting......

Sunday, September 29, 2013

Gardenhires Future

The Minnesota Twins 2013 season mercifully comes to a close today after a 3rd straight 90+ loss season.

Many fans and of course the media who like to run people out of town they can't control are calling for the head of Ron Gardenhire. 
How is it Ron Gardenhires fault his roster has been decimated by poor decisions from upper management? This is a coach 2 wins shy, going into today, of 1000 wins for his career. Only Tom Kelly has surpassed that mark for the Twins and not many others have in MLB history.

You can't even call what has happened to the Twins roster a typical fire sale, it is attrition through upper management ineptitude.

After Terry Ryan retired as G.M. and handed the reigns to Bill Smith, he left a strong roster with an adequately stacked cupboard.

Bill Smith released minor league players with a strong upside rather than trade them and get some return. The trades he did make, brought little in return.

He allowed players like Jesse Crain & Matt Guerrier to walk, again with nothing in return. Jason Kubel could've been moved when he still had value but nothing. Michael Cuddyer showed some interest early in resigning here but was rebuked only to leave and again nothing in return.

Mercifully before the 2012 season the Pohlad's fired that ass clown. They brought back Terry Ryan who previously had success at the helm. The problem with Terry Ryan is his approach takes time to yield results. In addition he has a lot of damage to undo from the Smith debacle. After 3 consecutive pathetic seasons and a brand new taxpayer funded stadium that is top 5 in the country at least, fans are impatient and angry.

At the end of the 2013 season Ryan jettisoned Justin Morneu and shipped him to Pittsburgh for another one of no less than a dozen 4th or 5th OF candidates. Now in addition to our previous problems we have a hole at first base with no other hitter that can consistently drive in runs.

Meanwhile we keep the $164 million man that can hit singles with the best of them while the bases are empty but rarely comes through when it matters. A move that severely hamstrings the team financially.

Bottom line Ron Gardenhire has not been given the assets to do his job properly. In addition, his coaching staff was turned over prior to this season resulting in numerous adjustments, with a roster that is constantly in flux because there is nothing left.  That is until the next generation of core players, which are 2-4 years away at best, are ready.

Ron Gardenhire and his staff deserve another year with a GM making an effort to give him at the very least a competitive roster if not a strong one. He deserves that chance and even more so the people of Minnesota deserve that.